• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Pizzeria Scotty

At Pizzeria Scotty, we celebrate the art of pizza-making with a passion for quality and flavor. Nestled in West Allis, Wisconsin, this casual eatery is renowned for its delicious pizza, including standout options like the BBQ Chicken Deluxe, crafted with fresh ingredients. We take pride in offering a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for families and groups alike, with convenient amenities such as outdoor seating, delivery, and takeout services. Vegetarian options abound, ensuring every guest finds something to love. Pizzeria Scotty is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub where flavor and tradition combine to create memorable dining experiences.

Pizzeria Scotty: Reviews & Ratings

The Gooseman
The Gooseman

Best pizza in town, if youre ordering the deep freid garlic sticks, get a full tray, youre gonna want more.

Sandra Petoskey
Sandra Petoskey

The pizza was very good, but their cheesy garlic bread is awesome. While they have 2 tables so you can eat in, its a pickup place. Order ahead as with their food being this good, theyre very popular.

Rick Sackett
Rick Sackett

Always top service. Had a miscommunication on a delivery order last week and they fixed it quickly and without additional charge. They handled it perfectly.

Jamie Wojczak
Jamie Wojczak

Hello!! Not only is this my FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE!! Best Pizza in Townnnn by far!!! But they also treat customers with the up most respect ...

Austin Hirsch
Austin Hirsch

Got The BBQ chicken pizza! Would get it again without a doubt! Really great pizza all together!

Chef Kayla
Chef Kayla

I help out here on the weekends. This kitchen is clean and runs like a tight oiled ship. So for the customer that means the food is always fresh. I like the pizza sauce more than most, the owner cares highly about quality product and ...

Justin Provance
Justin Provance

Finally tried this locally owned pizza place a friend recommend and am glad I did. Everything looked good and the most delicious smells filled the place. We ultimately couldnt decide so ended up getting a double dough and a stuffed pizza. ...

Adam Maglish
Adam Maglish

Havent ate here in person but this has become our go to for delivery. The wait times are just as long as any other place and I feel like the prices are better. The pizza is always hot when it shows up. Always plenty of toppings and always delicious.

Location

  • Pizzeria Scotty
    9022 W Oklahoma Ave West Allis, WI 53227 United States Hotline: (414) 543-1300

Welcome to Pizzeria Scotty, a delightful gem located at 9022 W Oklahoma Ave, West Allis, WI. If you are craving a slice of authentic, mouth-watering pizza, you’ve come to the right place. Pizzeria Scotty is not just any pizzeria; it’s a sanctuary for pizza lovers of all kinds, offering a diverse menu that caters to the needs of every guest.

  • Customization: One of the standout features at Pizzeria Scotty is the Build Your Own pizza option. With sizes ranging from 10 to 16 inches, you can craft your perfect pizza tailored to your cravings—whether you prefer a classic pepperoni or a creative vegetarian masterpiece. They even offer a gluten-free crust for those with dietary restrictions.
  • Wings and Pasta: The menu doesn’t stop at pizza. Their Regular Wings are a crowd-pleaser, available in generous portions, perfect for sharing among friends. Additionally, their Mostaccioli is a comforting option that features homemade marinara sauce served with coleslaw and french bread—pure Italian solace on a plate.
  • Atmosphere: The ambiance at Pizzeria Scotty is casual yet vibrant, making it a great spot for lunch or dinner. With outdoor seating available, you can enjoy your meal al fresco, basking in the lovely Wisconsin weather. The moderate noise level and family-friendly vibe make it an excellent choice for gatherings—be it a casual date or a family outing.
  • Convenience: Pizzeria Scotty prides itself on customer service. They offer delivery and takeout options, ideal for those busy days. Plus, with facilities like on-site parking and bike parking, getting there is a breeze. They even accept Apple Pay and credit card payments, so you can grab your pizza without any hassle.
  • Extras: For those celebratory occasions, Pizzeria Scotty also provides catering services, ensuring that your next event features their delectable offerings. And yes, they have Wi-Fi—perfect for catching up on work or scrolling through your favorite apps while indulging in delicious pizza!

In conclusion, Pizzeria Scotty stands out as a remarkable destination for any pizza enthusiast. The warm atmosphere, extensive menu, and unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction make it a perfect spot for dining in or taking out. So whether you're craving a classic pizza, succulent wings, or hearty pasta, make sure to pay a visit or place an order at Pizzeria Scotty.